Trying to ignore everything we think we know about money,
let's imagine setting up a new country - let's
call it Alba - and discover how to create a money system [*]
Creating currency, a tax system, and unemployment
To start with, there is no government; the population is beavering
away, living their lives as best they may, and then a group of
people decide that there needs to be services provided in
Perhaps the first service they think of is a police service that
monopolises physical power. The police service will need to be
given food and shelter, somehow, so that they can focus on
strutting around waving machine guns.
To give the police a living, the group creates unemployment. How do
they do this? They print a bunch of cards with the words "One Smackeroonie ($1)" written on them. The first police person
is Leon The Professional, and he sports a 9mm. Leon lets everyone
know that either they pay him $1, or they get shot.
This creates unemployment.
Suddenly, the tranquil world is seething with unemployment. The cry
goes up - I'll do anything to get me a $1. The group
behind Leon offer to employ people to build Leon a house and grow
Perhaps the group decides to only print 100 cards, but there are
120 people in Alba. 20 people get shot, which isn't a
good thing, but reinforces the idea that getting your hands on
Smackeroonies is not to be sneezed at.
This is how a currency, a tax system and unemployment are
created. The cards are a currency that everyone wants. The tax pays for Leon, the public service. Scrambling to get hold of limited cards creates
unemployment. In this way, the group achieves its aim of moving resources from the private to the public domain.
Creating a banking system
The group relents and prints enough cards to keep everyone happy,
and decides to call itself "the government".
Some people do more government work than required to avoid being
shot, and save a few $1 for a rainy day.
A second group of people - The Charlatans - get their hands
on a few extra $1 and, through advertising, create the impression
that they have bucket loads of $1 stored in their safe. People with
grandiose schemes, and people momentarily skint come to them for
It's all a confidence trick: The Charlatans do nothing more than operate an abacus - when someone
borrows $100, they rack up 100 negative points.
People with extra Smackeroonies ask The Charlatans to look after them - these people rack up positive points.
Luckily no one ever gets to see into The Charlatans' safe so
no one finds out the awful truth: there is next to nothing
However, this doesn't matter - so long as everyone repays their loans, there are no problems.
If anyone abuses the system by not paying back what they've borrowed, The Charlatans call in Leon The Professional.
The Charlatans decide to call themselves "a bank".
If a punter runs up a deficit with the
bank, eventually they will have Leon to reckon with.
The government is different. If it prints more cards and offers
matching work than is required to pay the tax, then the extra $1
remain in the economy and can be saved. A government deficit
(spending more than it receives) matches, identically, private
If the government issues fewer cards and work than is required to
pay the tax, the government drains Smackeroonies out of the
economy, leading, eventually, to people getting shot.
We see that government surpluses are bad; government deficits are
Why taxation? Why unemployment?
The common idea that taxation is necessary to pay for government
spending is nonsense, as can be seen from the process of creating
the currency described above.
First the government issues the currency. The currency is in itself
just a bunch of cards with no use nor value. They acquire value
only because of Leon the Professional. First, the currency is
issued, then the public pays it back as tax.
The government has no need for the cards - they will
typically destroy them in a shredder, and print some new ones. The
government can print as many cards as it likes - it is
impossible for the government to run out of its own currency.
The creation process also makes it clear that unemployment is a
creation of government. An unemployed person is
someone who cannot find the work required to get the money
necessary to pay the tax. If there is unemployment, it is because
the government has not spent enough (not issued enough cards and
The point of taxation is to move resources from the private to the pubic domain. Resources are real; Smackeroonies are
just cards. The government can use the currency or taxation to control certain economic variables, dependent on its ideology,
on which ... more later ...
[*]This presentation is a reworking of the videos by Warren Mosler, whom I find remarkably clear on money.